BLOG
Dutched Cocoa and Dutched Chocolate – What is it?
Key Takeaways
- Dutched cocoa is alkalized cocoa powder with a milder taste and darker colour
- The process was invented by Dutch chocolatier Coenraad Johannes van Houten in the 19th century
- Dutched cocoa has a neutral pH, affecting its reaction with leavening agents in baking
- It contains fewer flavanols and antioxidants compared to natural, undutched cocoa
- Some chocolate makers prefer using raw, unroasted cacao for even higher antioxidant content and complex flavour profile compared to undutched cocoa
- Dutched cocoa is commonly used in European-style chocolates, ice creams, and hot chocolates
- The choice between dutched and natural cocoa can impact baking results and health benefits
Not all cocoa is created equal – one significant distinction lies in the process known as “dutching” or alkalization.
This article looks at the nature of dutched cocoa and chocolate, exploring its history, production process, and impact on flavour and nutrition.
We’ll also examine why some artisanal chocolatiers opt for raw, unroasted cacao instead.
What is Dutched Cocoa?
Dutched cocoa, also known as alkalized cocoa, is cocoa powder that has undergone a treatment process to neutralise its natural acidity. This process significantly alters the chemical composition of cocoa, leading to distinct differences in flavour, colour, and functionality.
The dutching process involves treating cocoa solids with an alkalizing agent, such as potassium carbonate. This results in a less bitter taste and a darker colour compared to natural cocoa.
The method was invented in the early 19th century by Dutch chocolate maker Coenraad Johannes van Houten, hence the term “dutched” cocoa.
The Dutching Process: How It Works
The process of dutching cocoa involves several steps:
- Cocoa beans are cleaned and roasted
- The beans are then cracked and their shells removed (winnowing)
- The resulting cocoa nibs are ground into a paste called cocoa liquor
- The cocoa liquor is treated with an alkaline solution (usually potassium carbonate)
- The alkalized cocoa is then dried and ground into a fine powder
This process raises the pH of the cocoa from its natural level of about 5.5 to a more neutral 7 or slightly higher. This change in pH significantly impacts the cocoa’s behaviour in recipes, particularly its interaction with leavening agents.
Characteristics of Dutched Cocoa
Flavour Profile
Dutched cocoa is known for its smooth and mellow flavour. The alkalization process reduces the natural bitterness and acidity of cocoa, resulting in a milder chocolate taste. This makes dutched cocoa particularly popular in applications where a less assertive chocolate flavour is desired.
Colour
One of the most noticeable characteristics of dutched cocoa is its deep, dark colour. This darker hue can range from light reddish-brown to nearly black, depending on the degree of alkalization. This makes dutched cocoa a popular choice for achieving a rich, dark colour in baked goods and confections.
pH Level and Leavening Reactions
The neutral pH of dutched cocoa (around 7) means it does not react with baking soda, a common leavening agent. Baking experts explain that recipes using dutched cocoa typically require baking powder instead of baking soda to help baked goods rise properly. This is a crucial consideration when substituting natural cocoa with dutched cocoa in recipes.
Nutritional Impact of Dutching
While dutched cocoa is safe for consumption, it does have a different nutritional profile compared to natural cocoa. Studies have found that the alkalization process reduces the content of flavanols, which are antioxidants found in cocoa. This reduction in flavanols means that dutched cocoa may offer fewer health benefits than its natural counterpart.
Antioxidant Content
Research indicates that the dutching process can reduce the antioxidant content of cocoa by up to 60%. This significant reduction may impact the potential health benefits associated with cocoa consumption, such as improved cardiovascular health and reduced inflammation.
Mineral Content
Despite the reduction in flavanols, dutched cocoa still retains many of the beneficial minerals found in natural cocoa, such as magnesium, iron, and zinc. Nutritional analyses show that these minerals remain largely unaffected by the alkalization process.
Usage in Baking and Cooking
Dutched cocoa is often used in recipes that require a milder chocolate flavour and a darker colour. It is commonly found in European-style chocolates, ice creams, and hot chocolates.
Substituting Natural Cocoa with Dutched Cocoa
When substituting natural cocoa with dutched cocoa in recipes, it’s important to adjust the leavening agents accordingly. Baking professionals advise that the neutral pH of dutched cocoa does not react with baking soda, so recipes may need to be modified to use baking powder instead.
The Case for Raw, Unroasted Cacao
While dutched cocoa has its place in many culinary applications, some artisanal chocolatiers prefer to work with raw, unroasted cacao. This approach, championed by companies like Mr Popple’s Chocolate, aims to preserve the natural flavour nuances and nutritional benefits of the cacao bean.
Preserving Antioxidants
Raw, unroasted cacao retains a higher level of antioxidants compared to both dutched and natural roasted cocoa. A study conducted by Oxford Brookes University found that chocolate made from raw cacao had significantly higher levels of antioxidants and polyphenols compared to leading dark chocolate brands that used undutched but roasted cacao
Complex Flavour Profile
Unroasted cacao beans, particularly from rare varieties like Criollo, offer a rich, complex flavour profile with notes of red fruit, nuts, and earthiness. By skipping the roasting and dutching processes, chocolatiers and chocolate makers can showcase these unique flavour characteristics in their chocolate.
Conclusion
Dutched cocoa, with its smooth flavour and dark colour, is a popular choice in many chocolate products and recipes. However, it’s important to consider its reduced antioxidant content compared to natural cocoa.
Understanding the differences between dutched and natural cocoa can help in making informed choices in cooking and baking, allowing for the desired flavour and appearance in culinary creations.
At the same time, the growing interest in raw, unroasted cacao offers an alternative approach that prioritises preserving the bean’s natural properties.
Whether you choose dutched cocoa for its mild flavour and dark colour, or raw cacao for its antioxidant content and complex flavour profile, each option offers unique characteristics that can enhance your chocolate experience.
FAQs
1. Is dutched cocoa healthier than natural cocoa?
While dutched cocoa is not unhealthy, it generally contains fewer antioxidants than natural cocoa due to the alkalization process. Nutritional studies suggest that natural cocoa may offer more health benefits due to its higher flavanol content.
2. Can I substitute dutched cocoa for natural cocoa in recipes?
You can, but you may need to adjust other ingredients, particularly leavening agents. Dutched cocoa is less acidic, so recipes using it often require baking powder instead of baking soda.
3. Why is dutched cocoa darker than natural cocoa?
The alkalization process that dutched cocoa undergoes darkens its colour. The degree of darkness can vary depending on the level of alkalization.
4. Does dutched cocoa taste different from natural cocoa?
Yes, dutched cocoa typically has a milder, less bitter taste compared to natural cocoa. It’s often described as smoother and more mellow.
5. Is dutched cocoa suitable for all types of chocolate?
Dutched cocoa is particularly popular in European-style chocolates and in applications where a smoother, less acidic flavour is desired. However, for recipes that rely on cocoa’s acidity, natural cocoa might be more suitable.
Where to Buy Undutched Chocolate
For those interested in exploring the world of ethical, organic chocolate, including options that cater to various dietary needs, consider checking out our organic raw vegan chocolate bars.
If you’re looking for a guilt-free indulgence, our sugar-free chocolate bars might be just what you need.
And for those avoiding dairy, our dairy-free chocolate bars offer a delicious alternative.
Don’t forget to explore our chocolate subscription box for a regular dose of undutched and unroasted chocolatey goodness!